Having trouble posting this...keeps coming up BLANK on the Preview! 😕

One more try:

hi damir,

I read that on another site, the fellow called it "de-lidding".
I must've done something wrong because NONE of my non popping Foxtails germinated after this process.
But 25 Foxtails that did germinate were enough for me (maybe) 8)

Glad it worked for you.

Here is my failed attempt:
[url] http://www.palmsnorth.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=2588&highlight=delidding [url]

Barb

Something's wrong with posting...

Third try:

One more attempt to post:

damir,
Tried the "delidding" recommended by another site:
http://www.palmsnorth.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=2588&highlight=delidding

Glad it worked for you.
I didn't do it right, but had enough Foxtails anyway.

Barb

thanks for the tip Damir! In the past I germed Sabal seed at 90F (32.2C) inside a 'cooler' with a heating pad.

here it is pic of that one which germinates by that

How long did it take to germinate the sabal seed, damir?

I'm having no success with seeds this winter...nada!
Chamaerope humilis, Nannorhops ritchiana, Pritchardia hillebrandii, Cyrtostachys renda.

And only 2 Trachycarpus wagnerianus have popped, and they look weak and sick.

Your seedling looks very strong.
Barb

and here is how i did it. cut it with knife, not too much, keep in water for few days and there u go

So after waiting a year, you "de-lidded", placed in water and it responded within a couple of days 😀 😀

I'm worried a knife will dig in too deeply and kill the embryo.
Would sandpaper achieve the same result, but with less risk of damage?

I have to try that technique AGAIN with my seeds.
But it's only been 8 weeks...

Winter is so boring, and waiting for seeds is boring too. :book:
Barb

thats clever too barb. i think it will have same result. you should wait a while. mine were too long in soil without any results, so i didnt had nothing to loose. "operation" succeeded.

you should wait a while

Yes, a little longer.

Damir, you're a patient man to wait ONE YEAR before trying the operation 😉

Barb

nice photos Damir. Very interesting technique.

Barb, do you heat the seeds? I usually keep Sabals at 90F or so in slightly moist (not wet) peat moss. They popped in 3-6 weeks typically.

I might have OVERHEATED them 😆 next to the woodstove.

Last winter I used a germinating mat, near the stove, and almost all the Foxtails germinated.
Near the stove it's about 95-100F, drops down to about 80 o/nite.

In March when we seldom turn stove on anymore, I use the heated mat solely.

And in April I usually throw the seeds in the compost :bom:

Barb

Tried it today with 1 Pritchardia, 1 Nannorhops.
Think I went too far, it's so hard to see what you're doing when scratching it back and forth over sandpaper.

The entire center part of the Pritchardia got loose.
I murdered it.

<img src=" " width="500" height="375" alt="DSC04387" />

And the nannorhops feels like a marble. Neither knife nor sandpaper wore that bugger down.

0 for 2.

Barb

I'm going to try this method with some of my seeds, especially Jubaea. A guy on PalmTalk used it for a species of palm from New Caledonia. The seeds had never germinated for anyone before, yet they did when this technique was used!